Blog
Picking a web designer feels a lot like hiring for any other important role in your business, except most people go into it without a clear checklist. They ask a few friends, scroll through a couple of portfolios, pick whoever answered fastest, and hope for the best. Sometimes that works out. Often it doesn’t, and you end up six weeks in with a site that doesn’t look like what you asked for and a designer who’s stopped replying to emails.
If you’re trying to figure out how to choose a web designer for your project, the good news is that the decision gets a lot easier once you know what to actually look for. Here’s how to think it through properly.
Start With What Your Project Actually Needs
Before you look at a single portfolio, get clear on what you’re building. A five-page brochure site for a local business needs a completely different skill set than an e-commerce store with hundreds of products, or a custom web app with user logins and a database behind it.
This matters because choosing the right web designer isn’t about finding the most talented person available. It’s about finding the person whose specific experience matches your specific project. A designer who’s brilliant at sleek portfolio sites for photographers might not be the right fit for a restaurant that needs online ordering integrated with a POS system. Know what you need before you start comparing people.
Look Past the Portfolio’s Surface
Everyone checks portfolios first, and that’s fair, but most people stop at “does this look nice.” Dig a little deeper. Ask what the designer’s actual role was on each project. Did they design it, build it, or both? Was it a solo project or part of a bigger team where someone else did the heavy lifting?
Also look for range versus repetition. If every project in a portfolio looks nearly identical in layout and style, that might mean the designer leans on one template regardless of what the client actually needed. A strong web designer selection process includes asking whether the person can adapt their approach to your brand, or whether you’re going to get their signature look no matter what you asked for.
Ask About Their Process, Not Just Their Output
This is the part most people skip entirely, and it’s usually where projects go wrong. Ask how the designer actually works. Do they start with wireframes or jump straight into visual design? How many rounds of revisions are included before extra changes cost more? What’s the typical timeline from kickoff to launch? Who handles the actual development once the design is approved, them or someone else?
Understanding web design decision-making on the front end saves you from nasty surprises later. A designer with a vague answer to “what does your process look like” is telling you something important, even if they don’t mean to.
Check Communication Style Early
You’ll be back and forth with this person for weeks, sometimes months. If they’re slow to respond or vague in their answers during the sales conversation, that’s usually not going to improve once you’ve signed a contract and paid a deposit.
Pay attention to how they explain things too. A good designer can walk you through design decisions in plain language, without hiding behind jargon to sound more impressive than the work actually is. If you ask a simple question and get a confusing answer, take that as a signal.
Compare Pricing the Right Way
Price matters, obviously, but the cheapest option and the most expensive option are both risky for different reasons. Extremely low prices often mean templated work, limited revisions, or a designer who’s overloaded with too many projects to give yours proper attention. Extremely high prices don’t automatically guarantee better quality either, sometimes you’re just paying for a bigger studio’s overhead.
When comparing quotes as part of your selection criteria for a web designer, ask exactly what’s included. Does the price cover revisions, mobile responsiveness, basic SEO setup, content upload, and post-launch support, or are those extras? A lower quote that leaves out half of what you need often ends up costing more once the add-ons pile up.
Read Reviews, But Read Them Properly
Testimonials on a designer’s own website are curated by definition, so treat them as a starting point, not proof. Look for reviews on independent platforms, and pay attention to what past clients say about deadlines, communication, and how the designer handled changes mid-project. A pattern of complaints about missed timelines or disappearing after payment is worth taking seriously, even if the actual design work looks good.
Trust Your Gut on Fit, Not Just Skill
Skill gets someone on your shortlist. Fit is what decides who you actually hire. Do you feel comfortable pushing back on a design choice you don’t like? Do they seem genuinely interested in your business, or are they treating it like just another job on the list? A designer who asks good questions about your goals early on is usually more invested than one who jumps straight to showing you templates.
Choosing a web designer for your project ultimately comes down to matching skill, process, communication, and price to what your specific business actually needs, not just picking whoever has the flashiest portfolio or the lowest quote.
A Quick Checklist Before You Commit
Before signing anything, make sure you’ve covered these basics: reviewed past work relevant to your industry, understood their design and development process, confirmed what’s included in the price, checked independent reviews, and had at least one real conversation where they asked about your goals instead of just pitching their services.
If most of those boxes are checked and the conversation felt easy, you’ve probably found the right fit.
Still figuring out who should build your site? We design and develop websites for restaurants, hotels, and hospitality brands, along with the logo and brand identity work to go with it, so your site and your branding actually match instead of feeling like two separate projects.
Get in touch with our team to talk through your project and see if we’re the right fit.
